|If You Can't Take the Heat|
|Season 1, Episode 12|
|Challenge(s)||"iron chef" cooking contest|
|Reward(s)||dinner of the team's favorite foods|
"Up the Creek"
"Who Can You Trust?"
Returning from the ordeal that is Boney Island, the campers are thrust into a cooking battle to serve the best dishes to Chris. Two campers' dark pasts come back to haunt them, and a certain prank may have gotten too far with disasterous results...
- Heather and Duncan's dark pasts are revealed
- The Boney Island Tiki is discovered
- Sara is eliminated due to Heather switching the votes